Skip to content
MHTF logo

Maternal Health Task Force

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Vimeo
  • Flickr
  • Email
  • About
  • Topics
  • Resources
  • Buzz
    • People’s Choice Buzz
  • Blog
MHTF Blog ›

Demanding Accountability Isn’t (Just) About Shouting and Making Noise: Reflections From GMNHC2015 Day 1

Posted on October 20, 2015May 16, 2017

By: Rima Jolivet, Maternal Health Technical Director, Maternal Health Task Force

Accountability ran through today’s offerings at the GMNHC, both those explicitly dedicated to the topic and others I attended. I chose the title for this blog from the opening remarks made by Betsy McCallon, Executive Director of the White Ribbon Alliance global secretariat, in WRA’s panel entitled “Demanding Accountability for Quality Maternal and Newborn Health Services: Lessons Learned and Best Practices”.

india citizens hearing accountability maternal health newborn health
Citizens Hearing in India (Photo: White Ribbon Alliance)

She pointed out that while demanding accountability might conjure visions of people protesting in the streets (and this is one important tactic), it is much more than that.

Accountability is a process. McCallon went on to define the demanding of accountability as a systematic process that includes analysis of barriers, identification of context-specific solutions, targeted goal-setting and attention to results, scaling up successes and learning from less successful attempts (my paraphrasing).

WRA National Alliance representatives described the steps they undertook to hold health systems and decision-makers accountable for commitments to ensure availability of emergency maternal and newborn health (MNH) services in Tanzania and Uganda, to legislate women’s entitlement to respectful maternity care through a Safe Motherhood bill in Nepal, and to hold facilities responsible for providing quality care in India through a cellphone-based citizen monitoring program that simultaneously educates women on their entitlements and empowers them to rate the quality of the services they receive.

Accountability is also a mindset. Accountability to stakeholders and beneficiaries has to be built into both the design and the evaluation of health programs and policies. Abhijit Das, from the Centre for Health and Social Justice in India, a panelist in the session titled “The Role of Evaluations in Bridging Inequities: Experiences from Latin America, Asia and Africa,” made this point passionately. He asked participants to critically question the assumption that the priority interventions for saving maternal and newborn lives are known and it simply a matter of getting them to marginalized communities in all corners of the globe, pointing instead to the great diversity reflected in these populations. He criticized the current strategy for addressing inequities as “policy fundamentalism”: to identify gaps and then simply intensify efforts using the same approaches. Instead, he exhorted the audience to listen to key stakeholders, to understand their lived experience and their key concerns, and to design and evaluate programs on the basis of how well they meet the needs and expectations of women who experience inequities in access, availability, acceptability and quality of MNH services.

Das pointed out that all women are concerned with survival of pregnancy and childbirth, for themselves and their babies; he said that by pushing people into a system they do not understand, that doesn’t match their experiences or meet their needs, and then faulting them for not complying, we convey the message that we believe they are naïve and ignorant and that we know best. He concluded that this leads to disempowerment of communities, and sets the stage for coercion and stigmatization of their already marginalized members within health care delivery systems.

In 2011, under the umbrella of the UN Secretary-General’s Global Strategy for Every Woman, Every Child, the Commission on Information and Accountability for Women’s and Children’s Health (CoIA) was created. One of the key goals of CoIA was to propel budget transparency to track the flow of resources for women’s and children’s health, and to monitor the return on investments in the form of measurable results.

Today, a multi-sector panel presented on the Global Financing Facility (GFF), a shared financing partnership created and launched in support of the updated Global Strategy 2.0 for Every Woman, Every Child and Every Adolescent, which aims to fulfill many of these functions. The GFF is a multi-stakeholder financing partnership that will pool resources from multiple donors, the private sector, and governments themselves, to ensure adequate resources are available to finance costed national plans that are based on context-specific priorities and national investment cases, and to track expenditures and return on these investments and deliver financing based on results, with the ultimate goal of enabling and accelerating efforts to end preventable maternal, newborn, child and adolescent deaths by 2030. Four countries, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Ethiopia, Kenya and Tanzania are currently in the process of developing investment cases and negotiating financing packages through the GFF. Civil society representatives are participating in every stage of the project to ensure that issues of concern to communities, for example attention to equity, are addressed. This financing facility delivers on the promise of CoIA.

Today’s panels demonstrated amply that demanding accountability for MNH is much more than (just) shouting and making noise.

Share this:FacebookTwitterLinkedInReddit
CATEGORIESCATEGORIES: Contributor Posts GMNHC2015 Series
TOPICSTOPICS: Financing Social Accountability Social Determinants

Looking for something specific?

Blog Series

  • Improving Maternal Health Measurement
  • Noncommunicable Diseases and Maternal Health
  • The Global Maternal Health Workforce
  • Quality of Maternal Health Care
  • See more>>

Archives

Blogs we follow

  • Healthy Newborn Network
  • Jacaranda Health
  • Jhpiego Field Notes
  • MamaYe
  • Maternal and Child Survival
  • NPR Goats and Soda
  • White Ribbon Alliance
  • Women Deliver

MHTF Disclaimer

The posts on this blog do not necessarily reflect the views of the Maternal Health Task Force. Our objective is to provide a platform for our Editorial Committee and other experts to post a myriad of data and evidence, as well as opinions/views that exist in the field which will contribute to expanding the maternal health dialogue.
  • About
  • Topics
  • Resources
  • Buzz
    • People’s Choice Buzz
  • Blog

MATERNAL HEALTH TASK FORCE

Harvard Chan School Center of Excellence in Maternal and Child Health
677 Huntington Avenue
Boston, MA 02115
MHTF@hsph.harvard.edu

This project is supported by the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) under grant T76MC00001 and entitled Training Grant in Maternal and Child Health. This information or content and conclusions are those of the author and should not be construed as the official position or policy of, nor should any endorsements be inferred by HRSA, HHS or the U.S. Government.
  • About
    • Key Facts
    • Renaming the School
    • Office of the Dean
    • Location and Facilities
    • Administrative Offices
    • Contact Information
  • Admissions
    • Office of Admissions
    • Harvard Chan Viewbook
    • Financial Aid
    • Registrar’s Office
    • Summer at the School
  • Academics
    • Departments
    • Degrees
    • Online Degree Program
    • Programs and Requirements
    • Executive/Summer Programs
    • Interdisciplinary Concentrations
    • Office of Education
    • Division of Biological Sciences
    • Division of Policy Translation and Leadership Development
    • Executive and Continuing Professional Education
    • Fellowships and Residencies
    • Academic Calendar
    • Harvard Chan Viewbook
  • Exec Ed
  • Research
    • Office of Research Strategy and Development
    • Harvard Longwood Campus Research Administration
    • Office of Regulatory Affairs and Research Compliance
    • Office of Human Research Administration
    • Centers & Institutes
    • Researchers Directory
    • Postdoctoral Research Fellows
    • Export Controls
    • International Research
  • Faculty
    • Office of Faculty Affairs
    • Office of Diversity and Inclusion
    • Faculty Directory
    • Faculty Searches
  • Students
    • Student Life Main
    • Academic Calendar
    • Career Advancement
    • Countway Library
    • Housing
    • Student News
    • Office for Student Affairs
    • Office of Education
    • Office of Diversity and Inclusion
    • Office of Financial Aid
    • Registrar’s Office
    • Student Billing
    • Orientation
    • Commencement
  • Alumni
  • News
    • News Main
    • Press Releases
    • Harvard Public Health Magazine
    • Explore Research by Topic
    • Mailing Lists
    • Multimedia
    • Office of Communications
  • Make a Gift
    • Campaign for Harvard Chan School
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Vimeo
  • Flickr
  • Email
Maternal Health Task Force Proudly powered by WordPress
 

Loading Comments...