Skip to content
MHTF logo

Maternal Health Task Force

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Vimeo
  • Flickr
  • Email
  • About
  • Topics
  • Resources
  • Buzz
    • People’s Choice Buzz
  • Blog
MHTF Blog ›

When Home Birth Is Not a Choice

Posted on April 20, 2018April 20, 2018

By: Sarah Hodin, MPH, CD(DONA), LCCE, National Senior Manager of Maternal Newborn Health Programs, Steward Health Care

The topic of home birth is often a contentious one, sometimes causing heated debates among researchers, clinicians and advocates. While advocacy efforts around home birth—typically in high-income countries—tend to center on women’s rights to choose where they will have their babies, it is important to remember that home birth is not always a choice. Particularly in low-resource settings, women sometimes deliver at home not because they want to, but because they have to.

Several studies have examined barriers to facility-based delivery. The groundbreaking “three delays” model proposed by Thaddeus and Maine in 1994 provided a framework for understanding why women may not deliver at a health facility. Geographic and socioeconomic inequities in access to facility-based delivery exist across the globe, reflecting the reality that some women are more likely to have a skilled birth attendant and essential supplies when they give birth than others.

A recent paper that was published in the MHTF-PLOS Collection, “Neglected Populations: Decreasing Inequalities & Improving Measurement in Maternal Health,” presented perspectives from women in rural West Bengal, India who delivered either at home or in a health facility. Researchers conducted twelve focus groups with nearly 100 women in an effort to understand the factors influencing delivery location.

Among the 55 women who delivered at home, 33 (60%) said that they had preferred to do so in a health facility. One of the barriers discussed was the unwillingness of family members to accompany women to the health facility.

“My parents-in-law were reluctant to take me to the hospital. So I was forced to stay at home. I wanted to go to the hospital but it did not happen.”

This finding is consistent with previous research that has identified inadequate social support from family and spouses as a challenge in this context. Other research from India has illustrated a connection between women’s lack of decision-making autonomy and a higher likelihood of home birth. Poor knowledge and understanding about reproductive and maternal health among men is another critical barrier to facility-based delivery in India.

Eighteen women who gave birth at home reported that they were not able to get to a health facility to deliver because the vehicle did not arrive in time. One of the issues that arose in relation to transport was a woman’s lack of education about estimated delivery dates and average labor durations, which hinders women’s ability to prepare a birth plan.

Based on these findings, the authors conclude with recommendations for research and practice:

  1. Researchers should collect data on women’s preferences for delivery location when examining determinants of home birth.
  2. India’s Accredited Social Health Activists (ASHAs) could play an important role in educating women and families at the community level on birth preparedness to increase facility-based delivery.

Quality, equity and dignity should be a central focus in efforts to increase facility-based delivery to ensure that women in India and beyond receive timely, high quality, respectful care when they arrive at a health facility.

—

Explore other open access papers in the MHTF-PLOS Collection, “Neglected Populations: Decreasing Inequalities & Improving Measurement in Maternal Health.”

Learn about distance as a barrier to facility-based delivery.

Share this:FacebookTwitterLinkedInReddit
CATEGORIESCATEGORIES: Maternal Health
TOPICSTOPICS: Barriers to Health Care Access Community-based Care Education Facility-based Births Human Resources for Health Male Involvement Social Determinants
GEOGRAPHIESGEOGRAPHIES: India

Looking for something specific?

Blog Series

  • Improving Maternal Health Measurement
  • Noncommunicable Diseases and Maternal Health
  • The Global Maternal Health Workforce
  • Quality of Maternal Health Care
  • See more>>

Archives

Blogs we follow

  • Healthy Newborn Network
  • Jacaranda Health
  • Jhpiego Field Notes
  • MamaYe
  • Maternal and Child Survival
  • NPR Goats and Soda
  • White Ribbon Alliance
  • Women Deliver

MHTF Disclaimer

The posts on this blog do not necessarily reflect the views of the Maternal Health Task Force. Our objective is to provide a platform for our Editorial Committee and other experts to post a myriad of data and evidence, as well as opinions/views that exist in the field which will contribute to expanding the maternal health dialogue.
  • About
  • Topics
  • Resources
  • Buzz
    • People’s Choice Buzz
  • Blog

MATERNAL HEALTH TASK FORCE

Harvard Chan School Center of Excellence in Maternal and Child Health
677 Huntington Avenue
Boston, MA 02115
MHTF@hsph.harvard.edu

This project is supported by the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) under grant T76MC00001 and entitled Training Grant in Maternal and Child Health. This information or content and conclusions are those of the author and should not be construed as the official position or policy of, nor should any endorsements be inferred by HRSA, HHS or the U.S. Government.
  • About
    • Key Facts
    • Renaming the School
    • Office of the Dean
    • Location and Facilities
    • Administrative Offices
    • Contact Information
  • Admissions
    • Office of Admissions
    • Harvard Chan Viewbook
    • Financial Aid
    • Registrar’s Office
    • Summer at the School
  • Academics
    • Departments
    • Degrees
    • Online Degree Program
    • Programs and Requirements
    • Executive/Summer Programs
    • Interdisciplinary Concentrations
    • Office of Education
    • Division of Biological Sciences
    • Division of Policy Translation and Leadership Development
    • Executive and Continuing Professional Education
    • Fellowships and Residencies
    • Academic Calendar
    • Harvard Chan Viewbook
  • Exec Ed
  • Research
    • Office of Research Strategy and Development
    • Harvard Longwood Campus Research Administration
    • Office of Regulatory Affairs and Research Compliance
    • Office of Human Research Administration
    • Centers & Institutes
    • Researchers Directory
    • Postdoctoral Research Fellows
    • Export Controls
    • International Research
  • Faculty
    • Office of Faculty Affairs
    • Office of Diversity and Inclusion
    • Faculty Directory
    • Faculty Searches
  • Students
    • Student Life Main
    • Academic Calendar
    • Career Advancement
    • Countway Library
    • Housing
    • Student News
    • Office for Student Affairs
    • Office of Education
    • Office of Diversity and Inclusion
    • Office of Financial Aid
    • Registrar’s Office
    • Student Billing
    • Orientation
    • Commencement
  • Alumni
  • News
    • News Main
    • Press Releases
    • Harvard Public Health Magazine
    • Explore Research by Topic
    • Mailing Lists
    • Multimedia
    • Office of Communications
  • Make a Gift
    • Campaign for Harvard Chan School
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Vimeo
  • Flickr
  • Email
Maternal Health Task Force Proudly powered by WordPress